For 152 years, Schuyler Center has been advancing data-driven, effective, public policy to create a more just, equitable New York, in which all residents thrive. The policies and investments we champion are those proven to prevent children and families from experiencing the hardships of poverty, ill-health, food insecurity and other challenges; policies that stand to transform the public systems that serve and support the well-being of New York’s children, families, and communities over the long-term. By those measures, this budget is disappointing, with nearly all of the potentially transformative investments falling out during budget negotiations.
A handful of new investments directed to supporting children and families experiencing poverty are time-limited and not designed with the intention of building toward a significant, sustained reduction in child and family poverty.
This budget cuts funding for the child care workforce, threatening to worsen the state’s already severe child care workforce shortage and capacity shortfall. It does not transform New York’s child welfare system to better support families. And it does not make New York a more affordable place to raise a family.
Failure to invest in policies that are proven to uplift children and families is not just a failure within a budget bill. There are real consequences. These decisions will be felt by the family whose child care program closes due to staff shortages. They will be felt by the child who cannot buy school lunch, by the young person exiting foster care who cannot afford rent, and by the parent struggling to afford the cost of living in New York State.
There are important bright spots. Chief among them: the inclusion of continuous Medicaid and Child Health Plus eligibility for children aged 0-6. Forty-five percent of New York children are covered by Medicaid and Child Health Plus. Eliminating the requirement for the youngest New Yorkers to re-enroll every year will help ensure children’s access to health services in the most critical years of their development. In addition, a 5% rate increase for Early Intervention providers may help stem the systemwide exodus of providers, which has resulted in gaps in services for young children experiencing developmental delays and disabilities.
We celebrate the budget’s addition of state funds to the state child care assistance program to both fill the hole left by the end of federal pandemic funds, and to expand the program. Also welcome is a small – but important – child care subsidy rate hike for providers offering care during evening, early morning, and weekend hours (known as non-traditional hours), and those serving children experiencing homelessness, as well as an increase in funding for continuing a small pilot project to provide child care assistance to families barred by federal rules from accessing child care assistance due to immigration status, or because they work episodic hours.
Schuyler Center’s assessments around specific policy goals are outlined below.
Goal 1: Child Poverty Reduction — Reduce child poverty and racial inequity, starting by ensuring tax credits, housing, and nutritional supports reach all families, no matter where they were born.
Does the FY 2025 New York State budget meet this goal?
No. The final State budget falls short for low-income families. The budget fails to permanently expand New York’s child tax credit or ensure the lowest income children receive the maximum credit; provide housing supports for low-income New Yorkers; or fund statewide universal school meals.
The budget includes a one-time supplemental payment of the Empire State Child Credit that will provide a boost to New York’s low- and middle-income families this fall. While the supplement’s structure is designed to be progressive, it still leaves the lowest-income families out of the full credit and creates significant cliffs as family income rises.
With a nod to extremely high poverty rates in three upstate cities, the Governor and Legislature agreed to a one-time distribution of $50 million to address poverty in Buffalo, Rochester, and Syracuse.
Too many children and families across the state experience the day-to-day hardships of poverty –struggling to afford rent, food, and daily needs. That is a policy choice, and it was made once again in this budget. The clock is ticking on upholding New York’s commitment to reducing child poverty statewide by 50% by 2033. Another year is gone.
Goal 2: Child Care — Make a substantial and sustained investment in New York’s child care workforce and extend the promise of care to all children in our state.
Does the FY 2025 New York State budget meet this goal?
No. This budget includes a reduced investment in the child care workforce compared to last year – a workforce overwhelmingly composed of women- specifically women of color and immigrant women, a workforce that earns less than 96% of other occupations. These cuts come at a moment when child care programs are already operating under capacity, even while carrying waitlists, because of workforce shortages due to low wages.
This budget also missed the opportunity to ensure that parents who work variable hours in retail, the trades, the gig economy, and food service can access child care by ending the State’s practice of tying child care assistance to caretakers’ exact hours of work—known as decoupling. Legislation to end this practice—which has disproportionately kept low-income, immigrant, and Black and brown New York families from accessing child care assistance—was passed by the Legislature last year and vetoed by the Governor, with instructions for the Legislature to take the issue up in budget negotiations. While the Legislature included this proposal in both one-house budgets, it was removed during final negotiations.
Goal 3: Children’s Health — Expand and increase investment in child and family health.
Does the FY 2025 New York State budget meet this goal?
Yes. The final state budget includes authority to seek federal approval for New York to ensure eligible children remain enrolled from birth to age 6 in Medicaid and Child Health Plus (CHP) health coverage — programs which provide no-cost or low-cost health coverage for eligible children.
Continuous health coverage will ensure that the youngest children on Medicaid receive health care during this crucial period of development.
A 5% rate increase for Early Intervention providers, together with a commitment to a 4% rate increase for services in rural and underserved communities, may help stem the systemwide exodus of providers, which has resulted in gaps in services for young children experiencing developmental delays and disabilities.
Goal 4: Child Welfare — Transform the child welfare system by investing in policies that foster transparency and accountability, prevent system-involvement and unnecessary, harmful family separations, reduce institutional placements, and support child, family, and community wellbeing.
Does the FY 2025 New York State budget meet this goal?
No. The final state budget took two small steps towards better supporting young people and families involved in the child welfare system: first, the Foster Youth College Success Initiative (FYCSI) is funded at $121,000 more than last year at $8.3 million, still below the $10 million needed to robustly fund each eligible student. Second, human services programs received a 2.84% COLA, which requires a minimum 1.7% targeted salary increase. This is less than the 3.2% needed to keep up with inflation and leaves out some human services workers (like those working in Preventive Services).
Missing are long overdue investments in Preventive Services and Attorneys for the Child that would strengthen children and families.
Next Steps Toward Investments that Support the Well-Being of New York’s Children and Families
In the two months left of legislative session, we will be working hard to secure passage of a number of laws designed to make the child welfare, child care, and health systems better serve and support families, in a manner that is more just and equitable.
We will also be working with state partners to ensure laws are faithfully implemented and that investments committed in prior years are directed properly. A chief area of focus will be to ensure state leaders are on track to fully attain goals set by the Child Poverty Reduction Act, which committed the state to cutting child poverty in half in a decade with attention to racial equity. We celebrated that law not only for its bold vision, but also because it calls for an advisory council guided by data and evidence to make truly transformative – and lasting – policy recommendations. To date, the recommendations of the council have been largely sidelined. We hope and expect that to change.
Healthy children and supported families are the foundation of a thriving society—these are the investments that pay off for everyone, now and for generations to come. We will continue working for transformative policies that will create a New York State that supports strong families, thriving children, and vibrant communities.
President Biden visits Syracuse today to celebrate the deal that will bring Micron Technologies to town; a deal facilitated in part through the federal CHIPS Act – a law that invests in U.S. semiconductor manufacturing, research and development, and workforce through direct federal investment and robust tax credits. Senator Schumer has touted this deal with Micron as one that should put “a smile on everyone’s face in Central New York.”
It is, indeed, an important investment in the economy of City of Syracuse and the region, promising to create thousands of jobs in the region, and to invigorate the local economy.
We also know there are additional ways federal funding and tax credits can boost local and regional economies, strengthen communities, and support hard-working families.One proven strategy is expanding refundable tax credits, like the child tax credit. These credits put money directly into the pockets of low and middle-income families, who in turn, bolster local economies when they spend those dollars at local stores, eateries, and businesses. When the federal government expanded the federal child tax credit during the pandemic, and distributed the credit in monthly payments, local economies across the nation saw a $19.3 billion boost in spending per month.
The child tax credit is among the most effective ways to quickly reduce rates of child poverty. The pandemic-era child tax credit expansion resulted in a nearly 50% drop in child poverty nationally, and here in New York State. Unfortunately, when the expanded credit was allowed to lapse, poverty rates rebounded to previous levels. Federal leaders, including President Biden and Senator Schumer, have backed recent proposals to expand the child tax credit, but to date, those efforts have been unsuccessful.
This failure is particularly devastating in Syracuse, which leads the state as the city with the highest child poverty rate; 46% of children in Syracuse live in poverty. Every child deserves a fair opportunity to get off to the best start possible. The city or ZIP code where a child grows up should not determine his or her chances of achieving success.
We urge President Biden and Senator Schumer to renew their efforts to pass an expanded child tax credit, and put money directly into the pockets of Syracuse families – and families across the nation – who are struggling to make ends meet. We hope that, while they are here in Syracuse, President Biden and Senator Schumer will take a look at the city and communities and understand that economic development means investing in jobs AND in the families and communities that make up New York State. An expanded child tax credit would be the boost to families we need!
New York’s State Budget Must Prioritize Affordability for Families– Schuyler Center Statement in Response to One-House Budget Bills
As New York families struggle to afford the cost of living, our state leaders have an opportunity to leverage this year’s budget to bolster family economic security statewide.
Schuyler Center is encouraged to see many proposals in the Senate and Assembly budget bills that will support children and families, especially those struggling to make ends meet. We appreciate both houses’ willingness to listen to the solutions necessary to make New York a place where families can afford to put down roots.
The inclusion of investments that will have the biggest impact on those with the lowest incomes must be a priority as the final budget is negotiated. These proposals include robust tax credits, continuous Medicaid coverage for the youngest children, and making child care assistance more accessible to the many parents who work variable hours in retail, the trades, and the gig economy. By uplifting New Yorkers most in need, our leaders can create more opportunities for all children and families to thrive right here in New York.
Among the proposals with the highest potential to cut child poverty statewide and make New York more affordable for families is the Senate’s proposal to create and begin to implement a new refundable tax credit, the Working Families Tax Credit.
Unfortunately, while all three budget proposals commit to maintaining New York’s historic levels of investment in child care assistance, none include a permanent, sustained investment in the child care workforce. This failure threatens to derail all the state’s progress toward stabilizing the sector and making care available for more children and families. [View Schuyler Center’s Policy Priorities for Child and Family Well-Being.]
Budget Investments that Prioritize Child Poverty Reduction
In 2021, the New York State Legislature passed, and Governor Hochul signed, the Child Poverty Reduction Act (CPRA), committing the State to take action to reduce child poverty by 50 percent. Schuyler Center spearheaded passage of this law and continues to hold New York State accountable for upholding that commitment.
Through the CPRA, New York’s leaders have committed to prioritizing budget investments that will do the most for those with the fewest resources. Accomplishing New York’s child poverty reduction goal requires focused budget and policy actions to meaningfully reduce poverty statewide. We are encouraged by several items across the three budget proposals, including:
Robust and inclusive child tax credits – Both the Senate and Assembly budget bills include proposals that would strengthen the state’s refundable tax credits. To combat child poverty and make New York State more affordable for all families, it is critical that the Enacted Budget include a sustained, robust, refundable family-focused tax credit that targets the highest credit to the lowest income-earners (without an income phase-in), and is available to those who file taxes, but do not have a social security number. The Senate’s proposal to create a new Working Families Tax Credit – which combines the existing child tax credit and Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) – would immediately drive a significantly larger credit to the lowest income New Yorkers, and longer term provide all eligible New Yorkers a greater credit, making New York State a more affordable place to raise a family.
Funding for the Housing Access Voucher Program (HAVP), as advanced in both Senate and Assembly proposals, would create a state-funded voucher. A commitment of $250 million toward HAVP would have a transformative impact by helping families exit or prevent homelessness
The establishment and funding of a permanent, statewide Healthy School Meals for All program, as is proposed in both Houses’ budget bills, must be included in the Enacted Budget. This would provide school breakfast and lunch at no cost to all students in schools participating in the National School Lunch Program – a strategy proven to reduce food insecurity among children and lift families out of poverty.
Investments in Health Equity for the Youngest New Yorkers
Schuyler Center is pleased to see the inclusion of continuous Medicaid and Child Health Plus coverage for children 0-6 included in all three budget proposals. Forty-five percent of New York children are covered by Medicaid and Child Health Plus. Eliminating the requirement for the youngest New Yorkers to re-enroll every year would ensure that those children have continuous access to health services in the most critical years of their development. We applaud the Executive, Senate, and Assembly for recognizing the importance of this initiative.
Helping Families by Solving the Child Care Crisis
Supporting New York’s families requires addressing the crisis of child care access, affordability, and availability. The state must make a substantial and sustained investment in New York’s child care workforce and extend the promise of care to all children in our state.
As a member of theEmpire State Campaign for Child Care, we appreciate the Senate and Assembly including $220 million in additional funds for child care workforce retention grants, bringing the total investment in the workforce to $500 million. While this falls short of the $1.2 billion that is needed, it is a critical investment in the ‘workforce behind the workforce.’ What is needed in the final budget, however, is a commitment to providing workforce supplements on a permanent basis – as recommended in the Senate resolution.
Transforming Child Welfare
The final state budget must transform the child welfare system by investing in policies that foster transparency and accountability, prevent system-involvement and unnecessary, harmful family separations, reduce institutional placements, and support child, family, and community wellbeing. While there was some action toward these goals, several needed investments were left out of all three budget proposals.
Additional investments needed to support youth and families involved in the child welfare system:
Add a cost-of-living adjustment to the child welfare housing subsidy and allow young people up to age 24 to access it.
Fully fund the Foster Youth College Success Initiative (FYSCI) at $10 million – The Senate proposes $8.2 million for FYSCI and the Assembly proposes $8.6 for FYSCI. By increasing funding to $10 million, more foster youth can achieve education success and support.
Fund a flexible 3.2% cost-of-living-adjustment (COLA) for human services, instead of targeting the COLA to non-executive positions, and provide $195 million in funding to restructure and raise rates for mental health services.
Invest $80 million to raise salaries and reduce caseloads for lawyers providing legal representation to children and families in Family Court. While the Senate proposes $20 million in funding for increased salaries, it is not enough; we urge our New York leaders to invest $80 million.
The Governor must advance policies and investments that will be transformative for New York’s children and families while making New York more affordable for all.
Following yesterday’s State of the State address, Schuyler Center for Analysis and Advocacy is encouraged by Governor Hochul’s attention to health equity, youth mental health, maternal and infant health, paid parental and disability leave, and making New York more affordable for families.
We are especially pleased to see that New York is poised to become the next state to provide continuous coverage in Medicaid and Child Health Plus for the youngest New Yorkers through an intent to apply for Section 1115 Medicaid Waiver authority. As supporters of this policy, we recognize that enacting continuous health coverage for children until they reach age six will keep New York on the forefront of protecting and investing in our youngest children and their families.
At a time when families are leaving New York State, the right investments can keep families here: learning, growing, playing, working, and creating a vibrant future for our state.
Unfortunately, many of Governor Hochul’s policies as presented fall short of meeting the great need that exists, and many needed investments went unmentioned.
As advocates for children and families impacted by poverty, we were concerned to hear the Governor use the language of shared austerity when referring to the state’s budget challenges, suggesting that all New Yorkers must tighten their belts. We urge Governor Hochul and legislative leaders to remember that children from working families and historically underinvested communities must not shoulder the burden of inadequately funded services so the State can close budget gaps.
Child and family well-being is the foundation of a thriving society—these are the investments that pay off for everyone, now and for generations to come. The right funding and policies can help us achieve a vision for New York State in which families can not only afford to stay in New York but choose to stay and flourish here.
There are four policy areas that would create fertile ground for child and family well-being, for all New Yorkers. We look forward to seeing substantial, meaningful investments in each of these areas in Governor Hochul’s Executive Budget:
Child Poverty Reduction — New York State must make good on its promise to substantially reduce child poverty and racial inequity throughout the state, starting by ensuring robust tax credits, housing, and nutritional supports reach all families, no matter where they were born.
Affordable, Accessible, Quality Child Care — It is time for substantial and sustained investment in a child care system that works for everyone. Child care costs are too high for most families, while at the same time child care providers are earning wages so low that they often rely on assistance to make ends meet. New York must invest in the child care workforce and extend the promise of care to all children in our state.
Children’s Health — The state must expand and increase investment in child and family health, including in mental and oral health, as well as in health coverage systems to ensure children have consistent, reliable access to health care.
Child Welfare —It’s past time to transform the child welfare system by investing in policies that foster transparency and accountability, prevent system-involvement and unnecessary, harmful family separations, reduce institutional placements, and support child, family, and community well-being.
We are ready to work with Governor Hochul and State Legislators to continue building a New York State that supports family well-being, in which opportunity is accessible to every child, and where families choose to build their futures.
For children in immigrant families, there can be many barriers to services that support well-being. On October 19, Schuyler Center hosted a discussion with immigration and policy experts focused on how New York can best support all children, why those investments matter, and opportunities to support the newest New Yorkers.
Lillie Hinkle, Associate Policy Analyst, National Center on Immigrant Integration Policy, Migration Policy Institute
Lillie Hinkle works on issues including refugee resettlement, unaccompanied children’s services, and access to benefits and services for immigrant families.
Prior to joining MPI, Lillie worked with the International Rescue Committee in employment placement and family mentorship, providing services to newly arrived refugee families in Richmond, Virginia. They previously interned with MPI and a 3D printing lab specializing in archaeological curation.
Lillie holds a master’s degree in refugee and forced migration studies from the University of Oxford, where they focused on the intersections of trauma and refugee service provision in the United States. During their graduate studies, they provided research assistance to the Rights in Exile Program, recruiting country-of-origin experts for an online legal aid resource network. They hold a bachelor’s degree in anthropology and philosophy from Virginia Commonwealth University.
At The New York Immigration Coalition, Liza Schwartzwald focuses on Early Childhood Education and Care, Adult Literacy, and Two-Generation work, and she works with the Director of Education to uplift educational opportunities for immigrant families and English Language Learners in New York in a holistic and integrated way. She previously worked as a Policy and Advocacy Associate at United Neighborhood Houses, where she worked on the Families United for Learning and Literacy (FULL) family literacy initiative.
Liza holds a dual bachelor’s degree from Florida Atlantic University in History and Interdisciplinary Humanities, an MSW from Fordham University, and a JD from Emory University School of Law. She is barred to practice law in New York State.
Carolina Tenecela starting working at Little Sisters in 2019 as an intern, and after transitioning to full-time employee, was promoted to Community Health Director in 2023. She has a very personal connection to LSA – her first encounter with the organization was at 2 years old when she was enrolled in the agency’s Early Intervention Program. Outside of work, Carolina enjoys absorbing the culture that New York has to offer by visiting museums and botanical gardens. She loves the city and is happy to be taking in its history after returning from her college state of California.
This series of virtual and in-person policy discussions kicked off in June 2023, and examines the intersections of child poverty reduction and other policy areas, including health, early childhood policy, and immigration. Panelists have included policy experts, pediatricians, parent advocates, NYS agency leaders, youth partners, and others invested in ending child poverty in New York State.
Centering Children in the New York State Budget– January 2024 webinar
January 12, 2024 at noon
As Albany gears up for the 2024 New York State legislative session, this insider conversation looks at what we expect (and hope!) to see in this year’s state budget and the investments needed to make New York State a place where families can afford to live, grow, and thrive.
In this webinar, Schuyler Center’s Kate Breslin and Dede Hill discuss budget priorities for New York’s children and families, answer questions, and share resources as we kick off 2024.
The Power of Guaranteed Income Programs– December 2023 webinar
There are several guaranteed income pilot programs across the state and country. These programs provide a basic income to participants, with no work requirement. During this webinar, panelists discussed lessons learned from these pilot programs, the experience as a participant, and how this type of policy can combat child poverty. View the webinar recording.
Panelists:
Steph Silkowski, Director of Policy & Strategic Initiatives, The Bridge Project
Children in Immigrant Families – October 2023 webinar
For children in immigrant families, there can be many barriers to services that support well-being. This discussion with immigration and policy experts examined how New York can best support all children, why those investments matter, and opportunities to support the newest New Yorkers. View the webinar recording.
Panelists:
Lillie Hinkle, Associate Policy Analyst, National Center on Immigrant Integration Policy, Migration Policy Institute
Early Childhood Foundations – September 2023, in-person event
This discussion with early childhood experts focused on the intersections of early childhood development and the experience of poverty, as well as the policy interventions that have proven to be effective for families. Held in Albany at The Bull Moose Club, the event brought together advocates, policymakers, community leaders, and state agency leadership. View the recording here.
The discussion was moderated by David Lombardo, host of The Capitol Pressroom, with panelists:
For families experiencing poverty, there are many barriers to consistent, quality health care. This discussion with leading child health and policy experts focused on how New York supports health for all children, opportunities for improvement, and recommendations for action that addresses health goals within child poverty reduction efforts. View the recording here.
Panelists:
Dr. Benard Dreyer, Pediatrician, NYU Grossman School of Medicine and Bellevue Hospital Center
Progress Update on the Child Poverty Reduction Act – June 2023 webinar
The first in our discussion series included the co-chair and members of the NYS Child Poverty Reduction Advisory Council. The conversation focused on the work the Council has done so far, goals for the coming months, and what lies ahead in pursuit of the Child Poverty Reduction Act goal to reduce the State’s child poverty rate by 50% by 2033. View the recording here.
Panelists:
Advisory Council co-chair Daniel Tietz, Commissioner of the NYS Office of Temporary and Disability Assistance;
Alyson Tarek, Assistant Secretary for Human Services and Mental Hygiene, NYS Executive Chamber; and
Advisory Council member Candace Cabral, Parent Advocate.
Recent Comments